Is purple grape juice really the answer to all our ills?
I was interested recently to read the results of the study which assessed the ‘antioxidant’ potential of several types of fruit juices and fruit drinks [1]. Of the 13 types of fruit juice tested, red grape juice came out on top with regard to antioxidant action, which appears to be related to its rich content of potentially disease-protective plant substances known as ‘polyphenols’. This study has led to purple grape juice being hailed as the king of fruit juices.
However, before we go scootling down to the supermarket for a dose of this latest superfood, we might do well to consider purple grape juice’s prime constituent – sugar.
Like all fruit juices, purple grape juice is rammed full of the stuff. One prominent brand contains 40 g of sugar per 240 ml serving. That works out at 16.66 g of sugar per 100 mls of drink. Coca-cola, on the other hand, contains 35 g of sugar per 330 mls. Which works out at 10.6 g of sugar per 100 mls.
What this means is that purple grape juice contains more than 50 per cent MORE sugar than Coca Cola.
Could it be that this glut of sugar might offset some of the healthy properties ascribed to the polyphenols in purple grape juice? That’s a rhetorical question, obviously.
The sugar in fruit juices such as purple grape juice comes, essentially, in the forms of glucose and fructose. As I have written before on this site and elsewhere, while fructose is often seen as a ‘healthy’ form of sugar, the evidence suggests that it is anything but.
Just this week, for instance, a study was published which showed the considerable potential this form of sugar has to harm health. The study, published in the journal Hepatology, fed rats with a sugar solution containing either glucose or fructose [2].
Two notable effects of feeding fructose to rats were:
* Increased fat production in the liver
* Reduced effectiveness of the protein ‘leptin’ (among other things, leptin reduces fat production and enhances fat burning in the body)
In this study, some of the negative effects of fructose were found to be the result of impairment of the function of a receptor known as PPAR-alpha. This receptor is present in humans, and its activity in our species is lower than that in rats. This led one of the authors of the Hepatology study to speculate that the effect of fructose in humans should cause even worse effects than those revealed in rats.
There seems every reason to believe that the consumption of fructose might contribute to the rapidly rising rates of obesity seen around the World.
Take all of this together and there is good reason, I believe, for individuals to consume fruit juices with caution. Focusing on their polyphenols content and antioxidant activity simply does not give a full picture of their nutritional attributes and likely effect on health.
It should perhaps be borne in mind that the recent study highlighting purple grape juice’s wonderfood credentials was funded by an organisation known as the National Grape Co-operative, a consortium of US farmers operated by Welch’s who produce (you guessed it) purple grape juice.
Regular readers of this blog may remember that I recently reported on a study which found that studies funded entirely by the beverage industry are some 7½ times more likely to report favourable results than research which has received no industry funding [3].
References:
1. Roglans N, et al. Impairment of hepatic Stat-3 activation and reduction of PPAR activity in fructose-fed rats. Hepatology 2007;45:778-788
2. Mullen W, et al. Evaluation of Phenolic Compounds in Commercial Fruit Juices and Fruit Drinks. J Agric Food Chem. 2007 Mar 16; [Epub ahead of print]
3. Study reveals the potential for the food industry to pervert the course of science
Published March 19, 2007 . Filed under: Food and Medical Politics, Unhealthy Eating!, Weight Loss
Comments
Write Comment
Get Dr Briffa’s latest book – The True You Diet…
The True You Diet helps you discover and explore your own path to optimal wellbeing. Take a step in the right direction right now and receive the unabridged introduction to the book and a True You questionnaire – FREE! Visit TheTrueYouDiet.com for more info |
See
how the UK’s top nutrition doctor “Makes diets history”,
giving you the low-blurb, high-fact option for the diet and lifestyle
that’s right for YOU - based on your body’s unique and individual
needs.Dr Briffa's free weekly e-newsletter - "A Good Look at Good Health" - delivered straight to your inbox
Sign-up now and get Dr John Briffa's Natural Solutions to Common Ailments - an A-Z guide to over 150 symptoms and conditions absolutely free.
Every week, Dr John condenses some of the most interesting and relevant health news from around the world into our free weekly newsletter that will keep you up to date with some of the most pertinent health stories of the week - delivered straight to your inbox.
Our thank you present - when you sign up for the newsletter, you will also receive a free copy of Dr John Briffa's Natural Solutions to Common Ailments - an A-Z guide to over 150 symptoms and conditions.
A word about the adverts that appear on this site
The adverts on this site come via a service known as Google Adsense. Adverts deemed appropriate to the content on the site appear automatically, and are not selected or vetted by John Briffa or any of the team at drbriffa.com. The site does not endorse any of the adverts that appear on the site nor the products or services they promote.
[...] Is purple grape juice really the answer to all our ills?I was interested recently to read the results of the study which assessed the antioxidant potential of several types of fruit juices and fruit… [...]
March 19, 2007 @ 12:55 pm
Have it occasionally and cut it with fizzy water…
March 23, 2007 @ 8:23 pm
I would not compare good quality fresh grape juice to cola. It is rich in sugars but I suspect Welch’s grapes are also hybridised and selected for sweetness, also pasteurization increases the simple sugar content of foods. Chilled homemade, fresh juice from non-hybridised grapes (with viable seeds) is a great treat.
Be aware when you are being manipulated by marketing, all fruit and veg have anti-oxidants especially the fresh uncooked stuff. There are loads of free wild foods like dandelion leaves to add to salads and get berries from hegderows in August. Get a wild foods book and get out walking, it beats the supermarket on a Saturday morning.
March 24, 2007 @ 3:06 pm
Coco Cola may contain less sugar than grape juice but it also contains phosphates which inhibit the absorption of calcium.
Furthermore, the sugar in Coke is ‘extrinsic’ and therefore can cause fluctuations in blood sugar levels, which often result in sugar cravings - “more Cola” - and over-eating of the ‘wrong’, i.e. non-nutritious, foods.
Fructose is an ‘intrinsic’ sugar and therefore prevents fluctuations in blood sugar levels.
I suggest you drink grape juice for its antioxident qualities and dilute it with still (preferably) or sparkling water. It’s much more refreshing drank that way and beats Cola hands down!
March 24, 2007 @ 4:39 pm
Thanks Richard and Sylvia
I too believe that grape juice is healthier than cola - but just used cola to show how sugar-rich fruit juices like grape juice are.
The idea of diluting fruit juice with water is, I think, a very good one.
Sylvia - sugar in fruit juice is classed by the Food Standards Agency here in the UK as an ‘extrinsic’ sugar.
The low impact that fructose has on blood sugar levels has some relevance, but the point is that fructose does pose very significant hazards for our health.
March 25, 2007 @ 9:57 am
According to Jane Feedman M.D., Asst Prof. of Medicine and Pharmacology, “plateletsmin purple grape juicereleased 55%less superoxide..a free radical..which quickly inactivates the beneficial effects of nitric oxide”. It also contains the flavonoid Quercitini, which inhibits platelet activity. P.g.j.concentrate was declared to have this effect t the American Heart Assn’s 71st Scientific sessions in 2002.
According to Dr Folts, p.g.j. also dilates the arteries. Any comment?
January 16, 2008 @ 10:51 am