Vitamin D may hold the key for those who ‘hurt all over’

When I was at medical school and subsequently once I started working as a junior doctor, I encountered a number of patients who complained of ‘hurting all over’. These individuals were almost always of Indian subcontinent heritage, and were usually female. On examination, these patients generally claimed to feel pain wherever you touched them. In medicine, specific problems tend to produce pain in specific areas. Generalised pain is generally harder to diagnose. I’m afraid to say that many individuals with generalised pain did not seem to get the time and attention afforded to individuals with more defined symptoms.

My experience with these patients came back to me this week when I saw a patient in practice suffering from ‘fibromyalgia’ ” essentially muscular pain for which there is no generally recognised cause. Her symptoms are long-standing, and severe enough for her to need to take antidepressants (to help her sleep) and painkillers.

In the last couple of years, I’ve come to recognise that one relatively common but under-recognised cause of generalised pain/fibromyalgia is vitamin D deficiency. As most of our requirements for vitamin D come from the action of sunlight on the skin, vitamin D deficiency tends to be common in regions that don’t get a load of sunshine (like the UK). Also, the darker someone’s skin, the more sunlight they need to make a given amount of vitamin D. In other words, dark-skinned individuals tend to be prone to vitamin D deficiency. It is perhaps noteworthy that Monday’s patient was of Afro-Caribbean stock. Another thing that was noteworthy was that her symptoms resolved more or less completely after a few days in the sunshine when on holiday.

Needless to say, we’re in the process of getting this individual’s vitamin D levels checked. If it comes up low, then there’s a good chance her symptoms are caused, at least in part, by vitamin D deficiency. If that’s the case, then my experience is that’s there’s a good chance that boosting her vitamin D levels will help to relieve her symptoms.

I suppose I wouldn’t be writing about this were it not for an experience I had yesterday. I was just about to deliver a lecture to a group of general practitioners in the North of England. Before starting, I got chatting to a GP and the subject of vitamin D deficiency came up. He too had come across a lot of Asian patients who complained of generalised pain and tenderness, and some months ago had put two and two together and come to the conclusion that vitamin D deficiency was a likely factor in such individuals. Not only that, but he said he was getting good results with vitamin D.

Another reason for writing about this is that in the UK we are now well into winter, and the relatively contracted daylight hours will mean that our potential for sun exposure is severely curtailed. For this reason, those prone for vitamin D deficiency will tend to find that their symptoms are worst in the winter.

Individuals who suffer from generalised pain and/or fibromyalgia may want to consider vitamin D deficiency as a potential underlying cause. Vitamin D levels can be checked by measuring the level of 25-hydroxy-cholecalciferol (also known as 25(OH)D) in the bloodstream. I generally consider levels of 50 nmol/L or less as evidence of deficiency. If you are going to have your vitamin D levels check then I recommend working, if at all possible, with a practitioner who has access to such tests and can monitor treatment should this be deemed appropriate.

Getting vitamin D levels up in the body can be achieved through sun exposure and/or supplementation. While the recommended daily amount of vitamin D is 400 IU in the UK, I usually recommend much higher doses (usually in the region of 2000 IU per day) where there is evidence of deficiency. Such dosages are believed to be safe, though I do recommend monitoring, partly for safety reasons, and partly because we want to be sure that the dosage and form of vitamin D being used is having the desired effect in terms of vitamin D levels in the body.

8 Responses to Vitamin D may hold the key for those who ‘hurt all over’

  1. ethyl d 21 November 2007 at 5:51 pm #

    Dr. William Davis, author of The Heart Scan Blog, advocates strongly for proper levels of vitamin D for heart health, and points out that supplements are only effective if they are gel-based capsules of D3, cholecalciferol. Tablets, D2 ergocalciferol, or prescription Vitamin D are not properly absorbed by the body and are ineffective.

  2. Cindy Moore 22 November 2007 at 12:48 am #

    I started taking Vit D several months ago. About 2-3 months after starting Vit D, I realized that my life-long insomnia was gone! (I’m 53) I’ve been one of those that could lie awake for hours…..now I’m asleep within 15-20 min!!

    I’ve not noticed an improvement in the aches and pains, but krill oil seems to be relieving that!

  3. Edward Hutchinson 22 November 2007 at 1:08 pm #

    Googleing “Contemporary Diagnosis and Treatment of Vitamin D-Related Disorders” will bring up a series of Vitamin D presentations by leading experts in this field.
    May I suggest readers listen particularly to Session 4: Vitamin D and Population Health the session from Reinhold Vieth.
    Here he details the research showing that up to 10,000iu/daily are quite safe as 40,000iu/d for some months is required before 350nmol/l vitamin d status is reached and adverse events can be expected. However you will see from the slide 33 in Robert P. Heaney’s presentation how an intake of 5000iu/daily is more than most people would require to bring their status over 120nmol/l.
    May I suggest you leave session one until you’ve absorbed the other sessions. It really is quite hard going and although I think I understand what Mark R. Haussler is saying I don’t think I could explain it to anyone else in simple terms. The arrows by the slide preview can be used to fast forward if you need to skip the sessions you find totally incomprehensible.
    For those without broadband the full text of Vieth’s paper “Risk Assessment for Vitamin D” is online if you google and contains the same material as in his online presentation.

  4. Matty Maccaro 23 November 2007 at 3:38 pm #

    It is ironic that prescribing Statin drugs to heart paitents, actually wrecks havoc with vitamin D (and all other fat soluble vitamins) and consequently may lower your Cholesterol but leave you with a serious vitamin D deficiency. As one thing leads to another, the lack of vitamin D also makes absorption of Calcium difficult. Dr. Beatrice Golomb, who conducts the Statin Effects Study. at University of California at San Diego notes that Vitamin D deficiency is skyrocketing in Statin users. Because Statin drugs are one of highest profit and widely administered drugs currently on the market, physicians are reluctant to look at the down side of these medications, Vitamin D deficiency being a very negative direct effect of Statins.

  5. dominic gonzalez 29 November 2007 at 11:25 am #

    Interestingly, one of the commonest side-effect of statins is myalgia/neuralgia for which the statins are sometimes discontinued. Could this be a Vit D issue?

  6. Norma Laming 21 December 2007 at 2:34 pm #

    This may explain why fish oils are apparently the only thing definitely found to help rheumatoid arthritis and also why those with rhuematoid arthritis who live near the equator report less pain than those who live further away.

  7. Stephanie 21 March 2008 at 1:45 pm #

    Please email me at tysmoochy@aol.com if you can tell me why taking vitamin D might cause horrible pain in my body. I have fibromyalgia and I was under the impression that it was supposed to make it better. I stopped taking it yesterday in hopes it gets better. I’m going to have my doctor test my D when I go in next after not taking any for a whilte. Anyone that knows why I’d be in worse pain…please let me know.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Can aspartame cause muscle pain? | Dr Briffa's Blog - A Good Look at Good Health - 27 July 2011

    [...] muscle pain, and boosting vitamin D does seem to have the capacity to resolve this symptom. See here and here for some relevant blog posts about [...]

Leave a Reply